**The title, authors, and abstract for this completion
report are provided below. For a copy of
the completion report, please contact the GLFC via e-mail or via telephone at 734-662-3209**
Frederick W. Goetz2, Shawn P. Sitar3, Charles R. Bronte4, Penny Swanson5
2 Great Lakes WATER Institute
U. Wisconsin-Milwaukee
600
E. Greenfield Av.
Milwaukee, WI, 53204
3Marquette Fisheries Research Station
Michigan Department of
Natural Resources
484 Cherry Creek Rd.
Marquette, MI, 49855
4U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
Green Bay Fish and
Wildlife Conservation Office
2661 Scott Tower Drive
New Franken, WI 54229
5Northwest Fisheries Science Center
National Marine
Fisheries Service
2725 Montlake Blvd. East
Seattle, WA 98112
May 2010
ABSTRACT:
Lean and siscowet lake trout (Salvelinus namaycush)
morphotypes in Lake Superior are thought to be genetically separate but the
reproductive isolating mechanism is unknown. In this project we tested the hypothesis
that lean and siscowet lake trout are reproductively isolated by differences in
the seasonal timing of reproduction. The testicular and ovarian cycle of these
morphotypes were determined monthly from May to October in siscowet and lean
populations east of the Keweenaw Peninsula, and in May, August and October in
lean and siscowet populations west of the Keweenaw Peninsula. At each sampling
time, total length, weight, sea lamprey wounding, sex, visceral fat index,
gonad maturation (gross examination and digital photography) and total gonad
weight were recorded from each fish. Gonadal samples
were collected from each fish for histological analysis, and a blood sample was
analyzed for estradiol 17β (E2:females)
and 11-ketotestosterone (11KT:males) and pituitaries for gonadotropin
beta subunit transcript levels. In addition, during September and October of
2008, ovaries from 17 leans and 25 siscowets were
collected to assess fecundity. The gonadosomatic
indexes (GSIs; gonad wt/body wt X 100) for maturing
females and males of lean and siscowet lake trout east of the Keweenaw and for
siscowet west of the Keweenaw all increased from July to October. Thus, there
appears to be little difference in the timing of gonadal
maturation between lean and siscowet lake trout, suggesting that morphotypes in
these populations are not genetically isolated by reproductive timing. GSIs and histological analyses of the gonads indicate that
a significant proportion of lean and siscowet lake trout in these populations
do not reproduce each year. While the amount of spawning omission appears to be
about 20% of the population for each morphotype,
exact figures will require additional sampling over broader ranges of sizes
since this study was restricted in terms of the size of fish sampled. The percent
of spawning omission is likely to be much higher, particularly for female siscowets. Fecundity was significantly higher in lean
versus siscowet lake trout even though siscowets were
approximately twice as old. Lean fecundity was slightly lower than that
measured historically, and is likely related to density-dependent declines in
growth due to higher total lake trout populations and lower prey biomass. E2
and 11KT levels generally mirrored the changes in GSIs
for both siscowets and leans; however, while E2
levels increased gradually and continuously from June to October, 11KT levels
increased more abruptly in September even though there was a large increase in
the testicular GSIs in August. This suggests that
testosterone production lags behind the development of the testis. The beta
chain of the lake trout luteinizing hormone (LH) and follicle
stimulating hormone (FSH) were cloned and
quantitative polymerase chain reaction assays were developed for both. When
analyzed on a whole pituitary level, FSH beta subunit
transcript levels were low in May and June, increased in August and September
and then declined in October. This increase coincided with the largest
increases in GSI. Transcripts for the LH beta subunit were not observed in pituitaries until October
and only in some individuals. Overall, the results show that siscowet
reproduction is synchronous in a population and at least for the populations we
analyzed, maturation of the gonads occurs from July to October and is similar
to the timing of lean lake trout reproduction.